The new building for the European Central Bank (ECB) consists of two peculiar towers connected by diagonals. It is located in the east of Frankfurt, between the historic wholesale market, the Großmarkthalle and the Main River. The Großmarkthalle, an impressive brick building and monument from 1928 designed by Martin Elsaesser, was restored as part of its integration
within the construction of the new ECB towers. Due to the twist of the towers, also torsion effects had to be considered. The locations of the diagonal elements were generated parametrically in an
evolutional process.
118
thema
The European
Central Bank
1
The new building for the European Central Bank (ECB) (fig. 1)
consists of two peculiar towers connected by diagonals. It is
located in the east of Frankfurt, between the historic wholesale
market, the Großmarkthalle and the Main River. The Großmarkt-
halle, an impressive brick building and monument from 1928
designed by Martin Elsaesser, was restored as part of its integra -tion within the construction of the new ECB towers.
Due to the twist of the towers, also torsion effects had
to be considered. The locations of the diagonal
elements were generated parametrically in an
evolutional process.
Dynamic and exciting structure with twisted towers connected by diagonals
thema
The European Central Bank 3 2017
119
The architectural design process
The design of the new building for the European Central Bank
was developed during a competition in 2002. The geometry of
the striking 180 m high double towers follow the 'deconstructi-
vistic' idea of the architects Coop Himmelb(l)au to divide a
block diagonally, then turn the inner faces outside and the
bottom to the top (fig. 2). The two parts are combined into one
unit by a full height glass atrium.
The global structure design process
The stability system is based on the core walls of each tower. In
longitudinal direction the stiffness of these cores (fig. 3) was
sufficient to resist lateral loads. In cross direction the core
width is only 6 m. Thus the structural systems of each tower
had to be extended from two single cores to a global system
consisting of the two cores and a spatial truss system which
connects the cores via the atrium (fig. 4). The cores act as
Alexander Berger,
Manfred Grohmann,
Klaus Bollinger
B+G Ingenieure, Bollinger und
Grohmann GmbH
1
The Großmarkthalle and the ECB
towers
credits: Paul Raftery2 Design of the towers credits: Coop Himmelb(l)au
3 Element of the structural system:
the cores
credits fig. 3 t.m. 10: Bollinger + Grohmann4 Horizontal platforms and bridges
and diagonal struts
1) Deconstructivism is a movement of postmodern architecture which appeared in the 1980s. It gives the impression of the frag-
mentation of the constructed building and is characterized by an absence of harmony, continuity, or symmetry (Wikipedia).
2
3 4
The European Central Bank 3 2017
The European Central Bank 3 2017 120
thema
upper and lower chord of a global truss system. While the loca-
tion of the platforms, elevators and bridges in the atrium were
geometrically fixed, all diagonal elements were generated in a
parametric and evolutional process. The first models show
certain design steps of the process, the last one is the final one
(fig. 6). The governing criteria in this process were the eigen-
frequency and the stiffness.
Torsional effects
Due to the inclined façade torsional effects have an impact on
the towers. As both towers twist in the same direction, the
global structural system, apart from wind loads, has also to
resist these loads.
Slabs and columns
Due to the twist, all slabs have a different geometry and diffe-
rent span (fig. 5). The columns near to the façade follow the
incline, while inner columns are vertical and straight.
5 Slab geometry
6 Parametric design of the truss
system
7 Construction stage: while the
cores are nearly finished, the
truss system follows up from
approx. 60 m below
8 Installation of the trusses
9 Reinforcement of the
foundation slab
10 Bracing, bridges and
platform above
11 The finished structure inside
the Atrium
credits: Paul Raftery
6
5
7
8
121
Deformations and Pre-camber
The vertical and horizontal deformations of each column and
slab were calculated considering the construction process as
well as time-dependent factors like creep and shrinkage. These
deformations were considered during the construction process
by pre-cambering of these elements.
Construction process
During construction the structural system changed from pure
core systems to partially finished truss systems (fig. 7, 8 and 10).
For each construction stage the resistance of the structure had
to be proved.
The foundation
All the loads of the towers are transferred into the ground by a
combined pile-raft foundation (fig. 9).
Conclusion
With the construction of the new European Central Bank in
Frankfurt a highly dynamic and exciting structure was realized.
The design of the architects Coop Himmelb(l)au has been
accompanied by the B+G structural engineers from the very
beginning, i.e. already during the competition. Thereby, an opti-
mized structure for this building has been developed. Through its
expressiveness, it emphasizes and makes the seat of ECB archi-
tecturally appealing and standing out from afar (photo 1).
?
?
REFERENCES
1 Brensing, C., Bollinger, K., Grohmann, M., & Stracke, M.
(2015). Architektur und Tragwerk in symbiotischer
Beziehung - Der Neubau der europäischen Zentral-
bank in Frankfurt. Ingenieurbaukunst 2016, Berlin: Ernst
& Sohn.
2 Santifaller, E. (2013). Symbolic metamorphoses ? The European Central Bank building. Detail Engineering 3,
(1st edition), pp. 42-51.
3 König, G., Liphardt,S. (2003). Hochhäuser aus Stahlbe -
ton. Betonkalender I, Berlin: Ernst & Sohn, pp. 1-66.
4 Ruscheweyh, H. (1982). Dynamische Windwirkung an
Bauwerken. Teil 1: Grundlagen der Anwendung. Teil 2:
Praktische Anwendung. Wiesbaden: Bauverlag. 5
Krebs, A., Constantinescu, D. (1999). Der Einfluss der
Axialverformung der vertikalen Tragglieder von
Hochhäusern. Tagungsband Darmstädter Hochbau-
Seminar, Hochhäuser.
6 Eurocode 2, Design of concrete structures - Part 1-1:
General rules and rules for buildings. German version
EN 1992-1-1:2004 + AC:2010.
9
10
11
The European Central Bank 3 2017
Reacties